Clarity of Purpose: Many Educators continued to colloquially share Yellowdig as a "discussion board replacement" but stakeholders could no longer miss community-building as Yellowdig's actual intention.
"Community-building" is a also verb hinting at the Educators role in promoting results.
The change helped align every stakeholder group to actively pursuing student experience and retention as goals, even if they never communicated them between each other.
Thoughtful Adoption: Educators and Learners were more curious about "communities" and paused to consider how to approach them.
Obviously, you do not normally want to slow adopters, but most Educator and Designer choices were magnified through network effects and created transformational differences for many Learners (sometimes 1000's).
The certainty of weak outcomes of DBs and good outcomes from community methods made it better to risk some uncertainty.
I already knew they needed way less support later and provided better word-of-mouth; I was hired because Yellowdig had already been experiencing that detractors often have more impact than your happiest promoters.
Shortened Time-to-Value and Immediate Results: Some Educators had naturally been using "community" and community methods. I had plenty of field data showing students joining a "community" acted entirely different from day one. Educators and Institutional Leaders seeing the immediate positive behavior change and genuine student interactions were very often excited by them.
I had also run an experiment with big impacts; advising an Educator of a ~300 person class with DB methodology who was afraid to make a big change. I asked them to switch only "discussion board" to "community" throughout their course syllabus. About 150 more Learners participated in the first 3 days of the first week, rather than the last 3 days and that doubled engagement for 3 weeks.
Even without other, harder to prove evidence of longer-term impacts (e.g., better learning), those taking a supportive, community-building approach were more likely to start adding Yellowdig to more courses sooner and advocating to colleagues.
More Long-Term Efficacy: All initial data and instructor feedback pointed to Learners interacting with others and "belonging" to a community as causing people to like Yellowdig and to learn more and stay in school.
At the time of suggesting the change, those hypotheses were weakly supported, but pilots over the years showed DB designs produced few long-term benefits. With product improvements, using community methods was eventually reliably producing term-to-term retention increases of 5-10% while DB methods only ever achieved 0-1% (usually not statistically significant).
Market and Use Case Expansion: "Discussions" can only be used in courses and I argued communities could be used anywhere in any institution.
After making this change we saw an uptick in creation of non-course communities and more inbound interest from new stakeholders with new use cases, which eventually led to Yellowdig's three solutions.
Less Unlearning: Learners and Educators already knew DBs well and what to do. They all followed a well-worn path. The vocabulary change might require building new understanding, but it also required less unlearning or avoidance of bad prior methods.
Assimilating community into a rigid existing concept for discussion board had already proven difficult. In my first month at Yellowdig, after 15 minutes with an Educator new to Yellowdig, I had an interaction exactly like this:
Educator: "Ok, so I'm sure I have it, my students decide what they want to post. As they participate, they earn points from each other posting or commenting as they choose. I participate rather than grade and only take points if they are really off topic."
Me: "Sounds like you got it. So, just tell your students those things in your course design and remind them they can post questions. Participating is really for sharing things to help others or for getting help."
Educator: "Ok. I think I really get this. I'm excited to try it!"
Me: "Great, well, you have my contact info if you have questions. Anything else right now?"
Educator: "I think I just need you to show me where I put my questions for them to post about?"